淘客熙熙

主题:【原创】 关于北朝鲜是否侵略南朝鲜的思考――随便扯扯 -- flyingcatgm

共:💬39 🌺21 新:
全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖
家园 探讨历史,无非是以鉴明天。

朝鲜现在这么一个烂摊子,中国方面自然是不愿多讲。加上俄罗斯解密前苏联政府文件,一些海外华文媒体便开始趁机大肆渲染――标题无不冠以“从解密文件看中国真象”之类。

真伪果真如此难辨?是否比较公正的第三方不曾存在?现在节选一段。作者Paul Wingrove ,英国Greenwich U政治系讲师,文中引用电报来自解密苏联秘密档案。

Given that China was to play such a crucial role in the war, it is surprising that these Moscow-Pyongyang interactions were largely hidden from Mao. While some writers suggest that Stalin and Mao may have discussed Korea during the latter's visit to Moscow from December 1949 to January 1950, this was almost certainly not the case. Indeed, in a telegram from Stalin to Shtykov sent in February 1950 Stalin commanded that:

The question he [Kim] wants to discuss with me must be completely confidential. It should not be shared with anyone even in the North Korean leadership, as well as the Chinese comrades.

Although Mao was in Moscow until the signing of the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship on February 14th, 1950, Stalin chose not to talk to him about Korean affairs. Mao did not discover what was afoot until May, following Kim's month-long visit to Moscow in April. On Stalin's suggestion, Kim had travelled to Beijing to see Mao to lay out his plans. While Mao and Kim were in talks Vyshinsky, writing on May 14th, informed Mao that Stalin had already agreed to Kim's 'proposal', and hinted at a role for Beijing:

从以上看,中国方面的态度,截至派出志愿军前,一直是被动的,甚至初期对一切都是一无所知的。最让人不可思议的是,毛在访问莫斯科的漫长时间里居然一直被蒙在鼓里。

请注意:这个时候,也就是《中苏友好条约》签订期间,是1950年二月。而朝鲜师改编回国,是1949年7月。

试问一个对即将爆发的战争完全不知情的领袖,如何有预谋的派遣三个“国籍不能确定”的部队,去干预一场即将爆发的领国内战呢?

全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖


有趣有益,互惠互利;开阔视野,博采众长。
虚拟的网络,真实的人。天南地北客,相逢皆朋友

Copyright © cchere 西西河