主题:住宅旁的高压线对住户有什么影响? -- zhydrag
没有确切证据证明暴露在低频场中会导致包括DNA在内的生物分子的直接伤害.因此不太可能致癌.然而,关于低频场是否会影响癌症发病率的提高仍然在研究中.最近的动物实验没有发现低频场影响癌症的证据.
你说的"主要结论"是引用了NIEHS的结论.
"Possible human carcinogen" is the weakest of three categories ("possibly carcinogenic to humans", "probably carcinogenic to humans" and "is carcinogenic to humans") used by IARC to classify scientific evidence on potential carcinogens. IARC has two further classifications of scientific evidence: "is not classifiable" and "is probably not carcinogenic to humans", but the NIEHS Working Group considered there was enough evidence to eliminate these categories.
"Possible human carcinogen" is a classification used to denote an agent for which there is limited evidence of carcinogenicity in humans and less than sufficient evidence for carcinogenicity in experimental animals. Thus the classification is based on the strength of scientific evidence, not on the strength of carcinogenicity or risk of cancer from the agent. Thus, "possible human carcinogen" means limited credible evidence exists suggesting that exposure to ELF fields may cause cancer. While it cannot be excluded that ELF field exposure causes cancer from available evidence, further focused, high quality research is now needed to resolve this issue.
The decision of the NIEHS Working Group was based mainly on the appearance of consistency in epidemiological studies suggesting residence near power lines resulted in an apparently higher risk of leukaemia in children. Support for this association was found in studies relating childhood leukaemia incidence to proximity to power lines and to magnetic fields measured for 24 hours in homes. Furthermore, the Working Group also found limited evidence for an increased occurrence of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia in the occupational setting.
很长,不翻了.
大意是,美国人的研究认为50/60Hz的电磁场是可能的致癌因素.但"可能"仅仅是不能排除的意思.
而且,这个研究的证据来源是输电线路(不是家庭线路)附近住家儿童白血病发病之间的相关性.在职业工作人员(我猜是电路工作人员)对照组中仅有有限的证据( limited evidence )证明慢性淋巴白血病发病率的提高.
WHO认可的结论是
不需要任何特殊防护,有高强度低频场的场所是有护栏保护的,普通人无法接近,也不需要特殊防护.
- 相关回复 上下关系8
🙂我问的一个学物理的说法也差不多. zhydrag 字0 2010-06-10 03:19:19
🙂世界卫生组织有专门的网页说这个 1 山青青 字167 2010-06-09 09:37:27
🙂问题在于,知道有争议后谁再会拿自己当小白鼠去试一下? 山青青 字0 2010-06-04 15:30:03
🙂实际上早试过了。 njyd 字40 2010-06-09 02:58:34
🙂不能说油漆工天天在闻,住这个油漆的房间就是安全的 山青青 字172 2010-06-09 09:48:34